Hello everybody!
My most recent blog entry was about a proposal to re-name ESO’s telescope project currently termed “E-ELT”, and there were quite a few reactions on that. This entry is to summarise the arguments as well as the alternative names that have been proposed so far. Furthermore, I would like to announce the foundation of a facebook group “Re-name the “E-ELT”. Everybody is welcome to join and invite his/her friends.
I don’t want to repeat my own reasoning for re-naming the “E-ELT”, you can read it all here. The first obvious choice is to name the telescope after a famous European astronomer, so the name “Robert Wilson” was suggested. However, choosing names of astronomers from the history always has the disadvantage as to “favour” one or the other country, and since ESO doesn’t have a tradition in this respect, there will not be a balance between the member countries soon.
Next, Alberto Krone Martins suggests the name “The EYE”. Personally, I think this is a good name! Can somebody come up with an acronym that fits? Maybe this is not required anyway (there are alread too many acronyms floating around…).
Aybüke Küpcü Yoldaş from ESO proposes “The Answer”, because the E-ELT will provide the answers to important questions in astrophysics and it nicely refers to the 42 meter diameter via the Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy by Douglas Adams. Indeed, the number 42 seems to inspire some people, and I like this direction of thinking!
Franck Marchis from Berkeley informs us about why the American competitor of the “E-ELT” is termed TMT (Thirty Meter Telescope) at the moment. They want to leave open the possibility for significant private funding of the telescope, and would then name the telescope after the funder. For the “E-ELT” he suggests to continue naming the telescope after Mapuche words for celestial objects, as was done for the VLT unit telescopes.
Then, Alcides Dutra suggests a name from Greek mythology: CYCLOPS or Cyclopean Telescope. It fits this gigantic telescope really well! Luiz Otavio Mantovani thinks in a similar direction and proposes ARGUS, because it can see everything (”panoptes”). However, the name ARGUS is in use already for an instrument (or part of an instrument) at the VLT Paranal observatory.
A very important and interesting comment was posted by Markus Kissler-Patig, stationed at ESO and deeply involved in the E-ELT project. He suggests completely different directions of thinking, and also warns from picking a Mapuche name before the site of the telescope has been chosen. The different direction of thinking would be names of night-blooming flowers, such as Oenothera biennis or Mirabilis jalapa. This latter plant is very interesting, because it is native in the Peruvian Andes, and can change the colour of its flowers. Even flowers of different colours can be found simultaneously on the same plant. If a night-blooming flower (or a nocturnal animal?) is chosen for naming the E-ELT, it should probably be a species that is local at the site of the E-ELT. For this we have to wait for the decision on the site, too… In any case, Markus suggests to keep brain storming, and to start lobbying for the best proposed names.
Katrina Exter, who is from the same institute in Belgium as I am, asks why it should be called the “E”-ELT, meaning why emphasise the “European” - that seems a bit chest-beating. It could be called just ELT. This would at least make pronunciation a bit easier: Try to tell your friends about the “E-ELT”, and they will think that you are stammering…
Ulli Käufl, also stationed at ESO in Garching near Munich, suggests DAT - Douglas Adams Telescope, provided his family agrees. This also touches on the current proposal of a 42m primary mirror. I like this suggestion, too!
Finally, I for myself would like to suggest “THE telescope”, but admittedly there are better names among the suggestions above.
In summary, we now have the following suggestions (sorted by the time they appeared in the comments to my blog, no preference):
Robert Wilson
The EYE
The Answer
Mapuche name (of a celestial object), to be defined
CYCLOPS
Cyclopean Telescope
Oenothera biennis (night-blooming flower)
Mirabilis jalapa (night-blooming flower)
ELT
DAT (Douglas Adams Telescope)
THE telescope
Any preferences (vote for the own suggestion not permitted)? New ideas?
Looking forward to reading from you,
Stefan